Bass Pick vs Fingers – Which Is the Better Technique?

There is no right or wrong, better or worse when it comes to the topic of bass pick vs fingers. Both techniques have advantages and disadvantages. Playing with your fingers often gives a thumping, bassy sound, while a pick can give the notes a sharper attack.
Disregarding the vicious joke and rumor that only finger bass players are TRUE bass players, playing with a pick also has advantages. This is something that most bass players stumble upon by accident and just stick with it as time goes on. However, knowing the pros and cons of both techniques might save you some time in choosing the right one for you.
Let’s take a look at the advantages, disadvantages, similarities, and differences between playing with a pick and playing with fingers, along with a few related questions on the topic.
Contents
Bass Pick vs. Fingers
I’ll break down what each technique is good for or better than the other regarding sound, technique, speed, power, ease of use, and muting.
Sound
The first and most important thing to distinguish is the sound that a bass pick and fingers produce on the bass. While I personally like the finger-style sound better, the pick sound does have advantages and better suits some styles over the fingers.
Playing with fingers gives you more of a thumping, bass vibe that sounds more full, well-rounded, and vibrating. With a pick, the sound is more emphasized as the attack is different and harsher (striking), but the overall sound is more in the forefront which suits rock, metal, and similar genres more (usually).
Technique
The techniques are different, and each takes practice. With fingers, alternating your index and middle fingers is a useful starting point. With a pick, practice moving between strings as well as playing repeated notes on one string. Your fretting hand can use hammer-ons and pull-offs with either approach.
Fingers can make it easier to pluck non-adjacent strings together, while a pick gives a distinct attack. Neither approach limits you to one part of the fretboard.
Speed
A pick can make fast, even down-up strokes feel natural, particularly if you already play guitar. Fingerstyle players can also build speed by alternating fingers. Start slowly with a metronome and increase the tempo only when the notes sound even.
Power
A pick often gives notes a stronger initial attack, which can help a bass line cut through a metal or rock mix. You can play forcefully with either technique, though, and your hand position and amp settings also affect the sound.
Ease of use
I find a pick easier for some parts, but that will depend on your experience and the line you are playing. Try both with a relaxed hand and take a break if you feel pain.
Muting
Both techniques allow you to mute unwanted strings. Fingerstyle players can rest a finger or thumb on an unused string; with a pick, you can also rest the side of your picking hand lightly on the strings near the bridge for a shorter, muted sound. Fender demonstrates palm muting with a pick.
Overall
| Bass Pick | Fingers | |
| Sound | Sharper attack | Often rounder |
| Technique | Down-up strokes | Alternating plucks |
| Speed | Practice needed | Practice needed |
| Muting | Palm or fretting hand | Fingers or fretting hand |
Which technique should you learn first?
My advice would be to start with your fingers if you like that sound, then try a pick as well. If you already play guitar or prefer the picked sound, starting with a pick is fine. Learning both gives you more options for different songs.
What type of picks should you use for bass?
Not every guitar pick is “suitable” for bass. While any pick CAN be used, it is not necessarily good to use just any pick. Firstly, there are pick shapes that just suit your playing better, and those are the regular teardrop pick, the rounded teardrop, and the triangle pick.
A regular teardrop, rounded teardrop, or triangle pick can all work. Try different shapes and thicknesses to find a comfortable grip and the attack you like.
Secondly, the material of the pick is also important. You want something that feels natural to you, despite all the “rules”. Flexibility also plays a huge part here, as well as what sound you’re ultimately after.
Thickness and material affect how a pick feels and sounds, but there is no single required bass-pick thickness. Try a few options, including a firmer pick, and choose one that gives you control without gripping too tightly.
Conclusion
The everlasting topic of bass pick vs fingers boils down to the sound and feel you want. Both techniques have advantages, so I’d encourage beginner bass players to try both and choose what suits the song.

